Saturday, November 14, 2026

Ilhan saga began in 1990

The civil war in Somalia reached Ilhan's home in 1990/91, forcing the decision to escape to Kenya as refugees.

We are indirectly told that nine individuals related to the same deceased woman (who died between 1983 and 1985) went to a Kenyan refugee camp (probably near Nairobi) where they remained until 1995.

Before starting their journey, they adopted names and birth dates that may or may not have been legitimate.  All personal information provided to the refugee camp administrators was used thereafter.  They also abandoned a six-year-old boy who was their father's son, but related to a woman other than the deceased woman whose immediate bloodline they shared.

Eight of them also agreed to make the youngest individual (a girl) one year younger than she really was (stating she was born in 1982 rather than 1981).  They did this in 1990/91; the refugee documentation would establish consistency.  They also agreed on the family name they would utilize.  The two adults (both males) adopted different names within the traditional naming pattern and presented as the father of the seven youngest individuals and his father-in-law (their grandfather or father of their deceased mother).

In 1994/5, adult group members applied for asylum status and transportation to the United States at the Nairobi US embassy.  It was granted, and those who utilized the related permission arrived in New York City in 1995.  Government authorities and members of the group have not identified who actually entered the USA.  A few of the children took advantage of an opportunity to enter the UK -- where they became British citizens.

The abandoned boy, who claimed birth in 1985 (2 years and five months after the young girl, and apparently, based on her 1981 date, a full year after the death of her mother), was apparently also recovered and brought to the United Kingdom, where he too became a citizen as a child.  Around the age of 15, he entered the United States to become a high school student, living with people other than his father and Half-sister, in a different district of Minneapolis, Minnesota.

Apparently, they lived about ten miles apart and, though his father and half-sister were American citizens, they did not do the paperwork needed for him to acquire derived citizenship benefits via his alleged biological father.

The government now seeks to prove the kinship through DNA testing.  Since the son does not share the daughter's maternal X-chromosome, and does not inherit his paternal grandmother's X-chromosome from his father, the father's Y-chromosome must be used to establish their genetic relationship.  The majority of DNA could only establish that the boy is Somalian, or a general relative.  A Y-chromosome match would indicate he was in the same male line as the suspected father; other matches establish the direct connection.

Asked if he was a relative, she is on record publicly saying "not to my knowledge".

STRUCTURAL ISSUES THAT NEED TO BE FACTUALLY SPECIFIC!

We can begin with a verified real name if one on record is challenged.  These would be in Somalia, and, as his father was a military officer, that would be the source.  As an officer, one or more of his children might have been born in a military medical facility, which would be the source for their records.  They might also have his wife's death record.  His death in America indicates he was born in July 1952 - no day is given.

A government letter stated they did an immigration- and citizenship-related search for the father using a date of birth of 1 January 1941.  Since they were searching for someone born eleven and a half years before he was born, naturally, they found nothing.

The youngest of the seven recognized children was born on 4 October; the disputed year is either 1981 or 1982.  No twins are mentioned; If we assume a child was born every 18 months, we can derive estimated ages in 1995, which indicates that the children would have independent paperwork.

There is an additional issue: the father spend two years in Russia as a Socialism student.  If he was in Russia, he couldn't be making babies in Somalia.  Thus, we need the precise time he was in Russia.  We know that, upon his return, he joined the military and moved up the ranks as an officer.  That needs to be reconciled with birth dates for "his" children.

Youngest: 4 October 1982;  Child 6.  4 April 1981;  Child 5.  4 October 1979;  Child 4.  4 April 1978;  Child 3.  4 October 1976; Child 2.  4 April 1975;  Child 1.  4 October 1973;  Probable marriage: 4 April 1972.  This would make the father 19 years and 10 months old at the time of marriage.  Reducing the daughter's birth date by one year does not affect the marriage year, since the age difference between the births could be reduced.

Consistent with the calculation: Ilhan’s sister, Sahra Noor, was reportedly born in October 1976 -- making her the third child.  TikTok has a post showing a 1997 British marriage document for Leila Nur Said Elmi, who identified herself as a 24-year-old “spinster” whose father is identified as “Nur Said Elmi,” a military officer.  This means she was born about 1975, making her the second child in our calculation. 

Based on the traditional Somali Patronymic naming custom, Ahmed Nur Said Elmi would be Almed, the son of Nur, the grandson of Said, and the great-grandson of Elmi.  Thus, the assertion that Leila and Almed could be siblings would fit the naming tradition.  But to make that connection, the prosecutors need to reconcile the names associated with Leila's father and those associated with Ilhan.

One reconciliation would be that the Leila on the British marriage document is not the Leila believed to be related to Ilhan.  Another is that Leila and Ilhan share the same mother but different fathers.  This latter option would allow that Leila's father was Kenyan-British and left their mother; he then, in 1984, had relations with another Somali woman, and she gave birth to Almed.  Thus, Almed could not be biologically related to Ilhan, but would be a British stepbrother -- one Ilhan had no basis to know existed.  

The alleged half-brother was born on 4 March 1985, so he is two years and five months younger (so indicating a possible common mother whose death was related to childbirth); if the daughter was born in 1981, the age difference would be 3 years and 5 months -- affirming a different mother, and requiring the government to establish her relationship to Ilhan's father.  It is not enough to establish that their DNA is Samolian; the X or Y Chromosomes are the only valid genetic link.

The comedy here is that they could be related, but not by their parental bloodline.  The marriage could have been a Fraud.  But it would be to give Islamic shelter to Almed because he is a Homosexual and would be killed by those following Islamic Republic Shia doctrines.  However,  in 2026 he did "come out" in relation to his work in Kenya -- which would be the source of his derived British citizenship and family ties.

That final reconciliation element validates the "not to my knowledge" comment, as it reflects a lack of understanding of how he and Leila might be related.  In that context, as established in book Jonathon' POTUS Cousins: The Interrelated Kinship of American Presidents -- an interrelated history of our times, did Donald Trump know that he and Marla Maples shared a common ancestor Who made them cousins?  Or, if asked about marrying and having a daughter with his cousin, would he also say, "not to my knowledge"?

MIGRATION FRAUD RECORDS THE GOVERNMENT MUST HAVE!

When the family applied for asylum, each adult was required to fill out forms that are legally required to be historically preserved.  They are made public on the individual's 100th birthday.

Until then, HSI, DOJ, and other law enforcement investigators have free access -- no court order needed.  The mentioned individual is entitled to copies, and others can make a FOIA request.

The forms include name, date of birth, military connection, etc.  Their parent or guardian would fill out the form for a minor; thus, any falsifications are the responsibility of the adult who provided the information and signed the forms.

In the case of Ilhan Omar, she has been described as arriving in the U.S. in 1995 as a child refugee (about 12 years old) from Somalia (via a Kenyan camp) with her father and siblings. Public reporting and her accounts reference refugee resettlement documents from that period.  Though she was 12 when she arrived (in the first 9 months of the year), she would have turned 13 in 1995.

In 2009, she entered a civil marriage with Ahmed Nur Said Elmi (a British citizen), and their marriage license has been published online, showing their birth dates and the legal name she would be known by after the marriage (she retained the name she was known by: Ilhan Abdullahi Omar).  For the investigators, it is a matter of comparing the marriage license to the asylum form.

As mentioned in The Tailor Trauerspiel: An Immigrant Life, the port-of-entry immigration officers were known to change the individual's name when issuing their papers; immigrants also "Americanized" their names in the years after arrival.

To assert that Ilhan's name was originally "Ilhan Nur Said Elmi" and not "Ilhan Abdullahi Omar" (which would have become her legal name upon marriage).  With her 2009 marriage, her legal name became Ilhan Abdullahi Omar, so there is no legal basis to assert a fraudulent name usage after the date of her marriage to (and subsequent divorce from) Ahmed Nur Said Elmi.  European tradition allows for the assertion that, upon marriage, her name became Ilhan Nur Said Elmi -- there is a question as to whether that complies with Somali naming customs; the DOJ or any agency bringing a name-related fraud charge would need to address that issue.

Bottom line: the DOJ could, following European tradition, say she was served a warrant stating Ilhan Nur Said Elmi/AKA Ilhan Abdullahi Omar.

However, for social media to assert that the Nur Said Elmi name sequence is her "real name" requires confirmation via the various original asylum documents and all related immigration documents, including Naturalization Certificates for her and her father (to verify his name from the original asylum to Naturalization usage).  It should be noted that naturalization often includes a recognition of the name the immigrant is to be known by - effectively the legal name change.

Omar's father, identified as Colonel Nur Omar Mohamed, died on 15 June 2020, at age 67, from COVID-19 complications.  The grave inscription says: AABE NUR, Son of Awo Yusuf, June 15, 2020.  Either the prosecutors or the defense will need to explain the name differences or inconsistencies -- which would be consistent with a Jewish grave, where the Jewish Bar or Bat Mitzvah name often appears in place of the European name.

As stated, HSI/DOJ already have the various documents, a fact affirmed by Ilhan in an interview where she said, "… the person (her father) who signed the paperwork and did it all is no longer here to answer the charges.  Even though they have the papers that he signed."

So we know that HSI and DOJ have the paperwork and know for a fact what the legal or original names were/are.  Moreover, those papers all repeat the birthday for both Ilhan and her father.

In addition, HSI and DOJ should have all the paperwork for her siblings -- which would either corroborate or refute the names and dates on their father's and sister's documents.   

If the documents affirm that Ilhan Abdullahi Omar is the name shown on her Naturalization Certificate, then that is her lawful American name.  If it states her date of birth as 4 October 1982, that too is the lawful date -- but the fraud charge can be  challenged if the challenge relies on her 1994/1995 Asylum Papers

Given that all the papers are signed by her father, not her, the fraud rests with him, and the Court might allow Ilhan to be denaturalized based on the birth date her father told her, and the authorities, was hers.  No Child remembers the date of their birth, and every child relies on the date their parent states.  As we have seen, the date conformed to the likely birth dates for her older siblings.

We do have a timeline issue with her father having studied in Russia and his time of service in the Somali army.  But that is irrelevant if both the birth dates of his children and the death date of his wife can be firmly established.  We also need the documents for Lelai the "spinster" -- specifically, how she became a British citizen.  If it was derived, her father would have to have been born before 1963 in the Somali-Kenya territory; then Ilhan's father is not the British Lelia's father.  The same should be said for Almed.

If it exists and is justified, the immigration fraud charge falls on Ilhan's father -- not Ilhan.  If his citizenship is posthumously revoked, Ilhan would still be a legal resident and entitled to naturalization.  Though it would mean that, currently, she would be disqualified from continuing to hold her congressional seat and might not be entitled to the earned pension.

There is no birth fraud unless Ilhan has her original birth certificate.  Both today and historically, birth certificates (and formal birth registration) have long been uncommon in Somalia. As of 2020, only 3–3.5% of children under age 5 had their births registered with any civil authority, and just 0.3% possessed an actual birth certificate. Civil registration did exist in limited form before the 1991 collapse of the Siad Barre government, but it was never comprehensive or universal. But it is unlikely those records, if they existed, were available to refugees and asylum seekers in 1991.

Therefore, there is no factual basis to challenge any dates presented on the refugee or asylum forms. Therefore, unless Ilhan's father changed the dates between filings in the immigration/naturalization process, there is no basis to challenge the date of birth he presented. That leaves Ilhan, who would have had to change the date on an official document -- a biographical record or website constitutes a correction of record if it is made to conform to the signed immigration documents.

Another aspect of the “fraud” is the government provided the transportation to and entry into NYC. Ilhan met immigration residency requirements, so if she were 18 or older, she would have gained citizenship regardless of her father.

There was no basis to lie about her age, since it did not affect her gaining citizenship status in 2000. And, as noted, if her gay husband were her brother – since he was “four” years younger than her when “their” father became a citizen – he was entitled to derivative citizenship as a Minnesota high school student in 2001

Given they have the documents, HSI and DOJ can be sued for false prosecution -- unless those documents meet the stated inconsistency criteria. Since Trump has openly promoted the HSI and DOJ actions, and is the Chief Executive who is their direct and ultimate boss, his actions are an abuse of power -- constituting a high crime or misdemeanor that justifies a Senate impeachment conviction. Failure to convict would imply treason on the part of the Senators -- unless the House fails to provide the document trail as part of their impeachment vote.

Plato observed: “Wisest is he who knows what he does not know.”

UPDATE

Social media has shown articles depicting Leila and her brother socializing with a known military terrorist General; this would be consistent with her military father and a British social network distinct from Ilhan's father. If Ilhan's father were part of that network, one would expect him to have chosen to migrate to the UK.




  






No comments: